College Football 26 is generally considered a solid, worthwhile purchase if you appreciate the college football experience and want the latest features, but opinions differ on whether it feels like a full new game or more like a DLC-style update to College Football 25.
Key points supporting its value:
It offers meaningful additions over last year’s CFB 25, such as deeper recruiting in Dynasty, real-life coaches, revamped Road to Glory mode, and expanded marching band songs and stadium traditions. These contribute substantially to the immersive college football atmosphere and simulation.
Gameplay improvements include smarter defenders who now must see the ball to make interceptions, formation and dynamic substitutions, and coach archetype progressions that add strategic depth.
Presentation is praised for enhancing immersion with true-to-life stadium setups, new mascots, and game-day rituals, making the overall experience richer.
Many players and critics find it an evolution of the revival rather than a mere patch, with tweaks that improve core gameplay and modes. Some even highlight earning CFB 26 Coins through play as a motivating factor to engage more deeply with the new systems.
Points criticizing it as more of a DLC or minor iteration:
Some voices feel the gameplay changes are limited and in certain respects a regression, such as slower player movement and lingering AI quirks.
The lack of a tutorial or clear learning mode detracts from the experience for new or returning players adapting to changes.
There are still some bugs and loading time annoyances.
For owners of CFB 25, some reviews and community discussions suggest that CFB 26 feels like a paid update rather than a full sequel, with argument that many changes could have been included in a free patch.
Price-wise, it is sold around $70, which feels steep for an iteration with mixed new content versus overhaul. Some players recommend waiting for a discount or using cheap CFB 26 Coins promotions to offset costs.
If you are invested in college football simulation, enjoy Dynasty mode, and value authentic presentation, CFB 26 delivers worthwhile improvements and is generally worth the price. However, if you own CFB 25 and expect massive gameplay innovation or a dramatically different experience, this sequel may feel closer to a DLC in terms of content and polish, making it reasonable to consider skipping or waiting for further patches. Your choice depends largely on how much you prioritize the fresh features and presentation upgrades over core gameplay revolutions and the value perception of an annual sports title.